41 Comments
User's avatar
Itztli's avatar

Love to see this!

I just started taking action after so much overthinking about a niche.

You hit it spot on!

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

I struggled with it too! You're not alone.

Expand full comment
Ishita Singh's avatar

Amazing. I approached this topic through my writing. You might want to check it out - do share your thoughts with me :) https://mastersoffate.substack.com/p/niche-flix-and-chill

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

I'll check it out!

Expand full comment
Joe Mullich's avatar

A lot depends on your goals for writing. If your primary objective is your own creative expression, you don't need a niche -- just write whatever you want. If your goal is to develop a readership, a niche can be an important marketing device.

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

That’s true, but you don’t want to get stuck too long thinking about what niche you’re going to target. You have to get going and you can figure it out along the way.

Expand full comment
Artemis Simetra's avatar

I KINDA have a niche, but not really. And it took me forever to learn that that is okay. I am a human of many interests. Thank you for this article. It’s a good one!

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

That’s how I feel too. I “kind of” have a niche. haha

Expand full comment
Megan Lee's avatar

Yes yes yes!!! Love this! If we don't LOVE what we're creating for the joy it brings us, why are we even doing it? It's so easy to get caught up in putting out content that "people will like" all the while ignoring what "you" like. Never ends well lol.

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

I agree that we have to enjoy what we’re creating. Otherwise, what’s the point of any of it? I could go sit in a cubicle again and get paid more. lol It’s good if what we like to create is also liked by others. That’s the sweet spot.

Expand full comment
Sarah Seeking Ikigai's avatar

I did pick a niche, but one that actually can be flexed to relate to pretty much anything and everything I've got an interest in as it relates to self improvement more broadly speaking hehe ... I think though that if I hadn't had that particular lightbulb moment I was in the right frame of mind to write simply as Sarah anyway, because whatever is your driver is also what others may resonate with if that makes sense... but yes, fully agree with the diving in and doing the thing regardless having SO SO many benefits <3

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

So you're niche is a little broader, and that way you can write about multiple things under that broader topic. That makes sense to me!

Expand full comment
Katie Donohue Tona's avatar

As someone who writes about 5 different things in my newsletter, this was an affirming read😄 I am my niche!

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

I love it!

Expand full comment
Jenni Delos Reyes's avatar

"Experience is the best teacher" - couldn't agree more, dont be afraid to get out there, youre not alone we can always learn together!

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

Sounds like a perfect plan to me!

Expand full comment
Indranil Maiti's avatar

Million dollar advices. "Take action' solves 99% of your problem. I also took probably 2-3 years just to START. Now I can feel that the best way to learn is to enjoying the journey and I feel this is the best thng about this journey. Unlike other 9-6 jobs here you get ample opportunity to learn everyday

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

Once you take action, the momentum keeps you going. It's just starting that is hard for so many.

Expand full comment
Juan Gonzalez's avatar

Everything became easier for me when I stopped overthinking this stuff and thought about why I wanted to write in the first place.

Since 2020 I started writing because it was a way to share what I know and have experienced with others in a way that's scalable and reaches more people.

Long story short. I didn't focus on me, but rather on the people that I wanted to help. And overtime, the "niche" or the "ideal audience" became clearer and clearer.

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

That's very smart advice. Thank you for sharing!

Expand full comment
Kenny Alami's avatar

You’re right. The more you act, the more patterns you’ll see emerge. Or maybe none emerge that you like and that’s okay too. I’m going through that in my freelancing. Not sure where to niche down and where there is enough demand. Tough nut to crack but that’s what makes life interesting!

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

That's a very good point. You have to keep trying and following the clues along the way until you're led to the things that are most satisfying. It definitely keeps life interesting!

Expand full comment
Kenny Alami's avatar

Like a treasure hunt, haha!

Expand full comment
Samuele Onelia 🤠's avatar

The best way to define your niche is to create content.

There's no theoretical exercise that will remove this part or give you absolute certainty.

Instead, if you create content and see growth, then you have a reliable feedback from the market.

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

Yup! I agree. You have to get stuff out there and see what happens.

Expand full comment
Alberto Cabas Vidani's avatar

Often people talk about choosing a niche without clarifying their assumptions. Do you just need a creative outlet or do you want to make money?

If it's the latter, you need a way to be recognized. Why should people choose you? This usually takes the shape of a niche.

But there's confusion on the definition of niche. It's not just topics, demographics, problems ... The most helpful definition I found is "which transformation do you want to help your audience achieve?"

In any case, there's no amount of thinking that can reveal the perfect niche before starting to publish. Just make an educated guess, something a bit specific but not too much, start publishing and adjust based on your results.

Expand full comment
Jenn- jscreative's avatar

I like that definition of a niche! 💎

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

This is excellent advice. You are not going to reveal the perfect niche until you start publishing. The niche will find you along the way.

Expand full comment
Mike's avatar

My analytical brain is buffering.

I’m not the only one with notebooks full of “ideas”.

Expand full comment
Jenn- jscreative's avatar

You’re totally not!! 😛

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

Haha nope! You're not.

Expand full comment
Matt Brady's avatar

I think the biggest limiting belief when we start writing online is “I don’t know what to write about”, which is then followed by all the gooroos telling us to pick a niche.

If I’m writing to grow my business, then sure. I’ll focus on a few main topics and try not to get into the weeds. But if it’s my personal creative outlet like SS is for me? I’ll write about anything.

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

Sounds like the perfect solution!

Expand full comment
Raphael Schagerl's avatar

This is so spot on, Christina:

"The more you write, the more you figure out what you like to write about and what people respond to. It’s the only way to know!"

Expand full comment
Christina Piccoli's avatar

Yup. Sometimes you just have to start throwing spaghetti at the wall and see what sticks. (Although, I don't really recommend wasting good pasta.)

Expand full comment